Enrollment Analytics Told Us What Happened.
AI Is Changing What We Can Do About It.

Enrollment analytics still matter. But even the most advanced only answer part of the question. AI changes that — though not on its own. Paired with serious behavioral analytics underneath, it compresses the time from data to implication to strategic options. That’s where the real gains are.

Last year Teege Mettille and I wrote a book, The Signal Solution: How Smart Colleges Stop Chasing Applications and Start Converting Students. Its core thesis can be simplified into a single question: if we all agree the enrollment environment has permanently changed, why would we expect playbooks written for a different era to still work the same way? And what should enrollment leaders do about it now?

No one yet has disagreed with me on the first part of that premise, but the second part generally creates some friction. And one of the playbooks that’s changed the least is how we get from data to a decision: on a strategy, an investment, an individual student.

We talk to a lot of enrollment teams every day here. Almost none of them tell us they need more analytics.

What they tell us, in one way or another, is that they’re out of room to think. They’ve got dashboards, scores, weekly funnel reports, the whole thing.

But our analytics, even the most advanced, still only answer a portion of the question. For the rest, we rely on the interpretation, understanding, and pattern recognition of the team. And that’s where we hit the cognitive ceiling. When we studied how admissions counselors actually spend their time, we found they were spending 30 to 50% of it just wrangling data and lists, trying to figure out who to focus on, why, and what to do next.

Think about what we’ve unlocked when we can look at 300 to 400 individual behavioral data elements, not serially, but concurrently, and turn those into individual meaning for each student. The reality is that none of us, present company included, could possibly process that level of data.

We’ve tried to simplify it into predictive scores. But in doing so, we eliminated one problem (trying to assess what all of the data means together) and didn’t solve another: what does this truly mean for each student?

That’s the gap I want to talk about. It’s the difference between enrollment analytics and what I’d call AI thinking support for teams. They sound similar. They’re not, and I think the difference matters more right now than it ever has.

Where the work stops

Analytics stops at a fact. Thinking support stops at a point of view.

Analytics tells you what happened, what’s happening, maybe what’s likely. Conversion by stage. Yield by segment. A propensity score. Deposit pace against last year. All of it matters. But it hands the hardest part right back to the person. A counselor looks at a 0.62 and still has to work out why this student is wavering, what it means, and what to actually say on Tuesday’s call.

Let’s put a name on that work, because we all do it and we rarely call it anything. I call it enrollment judgment. It’s what happens when we go into committee. It’s what our most experienced people are doing when they sit down with a newer counselor. It’s what happens when we sit in our offices with the dashboards, the reports, and the metrics, trying to work out what it all means. It’s some of the most important work in enrollment, and it’s always been done by hand.

Thinking support does the heavy lifting behind that judgment. It forms a hypothesis about why a student is behaving the way they are, weighs it against other explanations, connects it to what the institution can actually offer, and suggests a move.

So analytics says: this student’s engagement dropped 40% after the financial aid letter.

Thinking support says: this looks like a value question, not a cost question. Her pattern looks like students who enrolled once someone connected the program to outcomes they cared about. Lead with that, not another scholarship.

You can disagree with that second one. You’re starting from a reasoned position instead of a number.

Analytics scales data. Thinking support scales judgment. One is the instrument panel. The other is a sharp colleague reading the panel with you. And it never really finishes, because the student keeps changing and so does the read on them. A report is done when it’s delivered. Thinking isn’t.

Here’s what that looks like in practice. A counselor with 30 years in enrollment read a three-paragraph AI assessment of a student in her funnel. The thesis it proposed wasn’t the path she’d been planning to take. But as she read it, she realized it had picked up on a situation she hadn’t accounted for. It changed how she saw the student, and it changed her strategy.

She followed the approach. She built a much deeper, more substantial connection than she would have otherwise, matched what the student actually needed with the unique value of the institution, and secured the student.

How do I know the story? Because right after that, she walked into her Vice President’s office, told her what had just happened, and said something to the effect of, “This is going to change everything.”

That’s not the AI making the call. That’s a 30-year veteran’s judgment, made sharper.

The advantage has moved below the language model

A couple of years ago, if you wanted a written read on a student, someone on your team had to sit down and do it. Now you can drop a CRM export into ChatGPT and get three confident paragraphs back in about ten seconds. It reads well. It sounds like somebody who knows the student.

I get the appeal. It’s actually where we started as well. But it doesn’t work the way that we need for high-stakes enrollment. Think about what the model is actually looking at. Opened emails. A campus visit. A FAFSA flag. At best, the model is looking at too limited data and has to infer too much. At worst, it’s making assumptions based on hundreds of other institutions running old playbooks. The same milestones that told the school in our book’s opening story they were on track, right up until they missed by 250 students. The LLM doesn’t fix that. It just writes it up nicer.

That’s precision theater with better grammar.

When Teege and I wrote The Signal Solution, the problem we kept running into wasn’t a lack of data. It was a lack of dimensionality. We were counting milestones instead of seeing behavior. That’s still the problem, and a language model doesn’t solve it on its own. We fixed this by combining ensemble machine learning and massive feature engineering, hundreds of behavioral signals built around timing, pace, and change, with governed and gated LLM analysis, built specifically for the work of enrollment and the decision paths of students. The models tell the student who’s speeding up from the one who’s quietly drifting. The LLM works out what that means for each one. It’s slow, unglamorous work, and it’s the only reason the reasoning on top is worth listening to.

The writing is easy now. The seeing isn’t.

Why it matters more now

The economics of enrollment judgment have shifted. We’re asking smaller, less tenured teams to interpret more signal per student than ever before, and the traditional answer, another report or another dashboard, adds to the load instead of carrying it. Automating the task, rather than training the thinking, gives a false sense of scalability. You have more contacts, but not more understanding of the student on the other end of them.

Until recently, reading each student individually at scale just couldn’t be done. It takes serious behavioral analytics and a language model working together, and that pairing is only now possible. And as everyone adds agents and automation, sending the email faster stops being a differentiator. Knowing which email, to whom, and why is. And task-based outreach doesn’t prepare a counselor for the conversation that comes next. I don’t believe auto-tasking is the path to connecting effectively with today’s and tomorrow’s student. When everyone has agents, it’s the thinking that differentiates.

What this changes, and what it doesn’t

I’m not saying analytics are going away. But trying to run enrollment on our analytics, reports, and trends the way we always have is like driving across the country with the parking brake on. You’ll get there eventually, and it feels familiar. But you’re burning a lot more fuel than you need to, and you’re leaving serious horsepower on the table: better decisions, smoother operations, a stronger team. You can now mitigate the enrollment leakage that happens when team members turn over. A 26-year-old can operate with the collective wisdom of the entire team. A 30-year vet gets a second perspective that reinforces their strategy or proposes another option.

Even at the leadership level, with trends, market shifts, and high-level performance, we’re still relying on ourselves or our strategy teams to work out what it means, what the implications are, and what our options are. The compression of that time, from data to implication to creating and assessing strategic options, is where the massive gains are being made. And it’s happening at every level, from the VP setting strategy all the way down to the individual student.

I’m also not saying good directors and analysts don’t already think this way. The best ones absolutely do. The problem is that there aren’t enough of them, and they can’t do it for every student, every week.

And I’ll say the uncomfortable part too. AI reasoning can be confidently wrong. If you’ve been burned by a tool that sounded smart and wasn’t, your skepticism is earned. The answer isn’t to promise accuracy. It’s to make the reasoning visible, make it easy to push back on, and keep people in the decision.

The question worth asking

So if you lead an enrollment team, here’s the question I’d sit with. Not “do we have the analytics?” or “do we have next actions?” You almost certainly do. And you almost certainly have the data. Across the hundreds of models we’ve built, we’ve only had to tell a school no twice because their data wasn’t enough to build high-confidence behavioral models. Twice.

The question is: are we unlocking all that is possible from our data, our systems, our investments, and our teams? For the institution, for the team, and for the betterment of each individual student, who gets a deeper, more thoughtful approach to every interaction.

And this isn’t theoretical. It’s capability that’s here now, already in use. We can turn it on in days, and it immediately changes how a team understands the work of enrollment. It goes straight at the cognitive ceiling.

That’s what we’ve been building VantagePoint to do since day one. But whatever tools you use, I think the next few years belong to the teams that figure out how to scale judgment, not just data.

Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#analytics-told-us

Disruption or Innovation:
Which Comes First?

Enrollment teams are managing dozens of different systems and tools. Each one promised to make the work easier. Together, they’ve created a new challenge: more data than ever, and less clarity about what to do with it.

Enrollment teams are managing dozens of different systems and tools: CRM, SIS, financial aid, communications, event tools, analytics dashboards, high school visit portals, and more. Each one promised to make the work easier. Together, they’ve created a new challenge: more data than ever, and less clarity about what to do with it.

Now AI is layered on top of all of it. The Chronicle recently made the case that AI is here to stay in higher education, and I agree. Sitting on the sidelines is no longer an option.

But that raises a fair question for enrollment leaders: do we wait for disruption to force our hand, or do we innovate before we get left behind?

Institutions that wait often end up reacting because the situation has become acute. They add one more system to solve an urgent problem, and the complexity grows. The institutions that get ahead start somewhere different. They don’t begin with the tool. They begin with the decisions their teams make every day, and ask where better insight would change the outcome.

That also means being clear about what kind of AI fits the need. Institution-wide solutions, like AI built into productivity suites or campus platforms, are valuable for broad efficiency gains. But enrollment has its own rhythms, data, and decisions. Solutions built with domain intelligence understand the landscape and work at a much deeper level: the funnel, the student journey, and the signals that matter at each stage. Most teams will need both broad efficiency gains and targeted domain intelligence. Knowing the difference helps you invest where it will move the needle.

The cost of waiting is real. With fewer high school graduates on the horizon, rising competition for every student, and teams already stretched thin, each cycle spent on the sidelines is a cycle of insight your competitors are harnessing while you assess or run the same playbook built for a different era.

A few questions worth asking before your next technology decision

  • Which decisions matter most to our enrollment goals, and what information do we wish we had when making them?
  • Is this a need an institution-wide tool can meet, or does it require enrollment-specific intelligence?
  • Is this tool adding to our stack, or helping us make sense of what we already have?
  • Does it free our people to focus on students, or create one more thing to manage?
  • What does another year of waiting cost us in yield, retention, and staff capacity?

Innovation in this new era of enrollment isn’t about having the most technology. It’s about having the clearest path from data to action, in service of the mission.

How is your team deciding where AI fits?

Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#disruption-or-innovation

Melt Isn’t a Surprise.
It’s an Outcome.

A response to “Colleges Struggle to Stop Melt” in The Wall Street Journal

“Melt isn’t a surprise; it’s the outcome of a process that started long before. It’s the result of drift we didn’t see, or saw too late to do anything about.” — The Signal Solution

This is something we think about deeply. We not only wrote a book about it (The Signal Solution, with Teege Mettille), we build advanced AI-driven software, VantagePoint by enroll ml, to help admissions teams respond.

Roshan Fernandez’s article in The Wall Street Journal hits home.

Melt doesn’t just impact enrollment and revenue — it impacts expense. By the time a student melts, the institution has already spent the marketing, recruiting, aid strategy and counselor time to get them that far, only to lose the student at the very end.

For anyone responsible for a college budget, the uncertainty around melt is one of the hardest parts of the job. I’ve experienced that firsthand.

There’s no secret “easy button” for this, and tactics alone won’t fix it, because the signals of enrollment have changed.

A deposit used to mean a decision. Now, for many students, it means they want to keep the option open.

If we treat the deposit as the leading signal, we spend our time on deposited students, including some whose behavior is already telling us they may not be coming, while missing the “movable middle”: students who haven’t deposited yet, but are still very much in play.

That’s the compounding cost of melt: It isn’t just the student who leaves. It’s also the student we never got because we were focused somewhere else.

So what should institutions be doing?

  1. Build deeper connection, earlier — not just more contact. Parent engagement. A clearer sense of value and belonging. Don’t confuse the old signals with the new.
  2. Identify drift before it becomes melt. A deposit can’t be treated as a binary signal of commitment. For example, VantagePoint reads 400–800 real-time behavioral signals per student, including timing and, importantly, silence, to identify with machine learning and large language models who is drifting and who is still movable, deposited or not.
  3. Engage the institution. At one of our state flagship partners, more than 45 faculty and department heads work inside VantagePoint to focus attention and discussion where it has the best chance to matter. They are focused and precise.
  4. Understand where each student actually is in the decision and meet them there. In the book, we call it Objective, Subjective, Objective: Do you have what I need? Can I see myself there? How do I make this happen?

A deposited student can still be unsure. A non-deposited student can still be leaning toward you. Respond to the stage of the student, not the stage in the CRM.

Melt isn’t an August problem. By August, it’s usually an outcome. The new playbook for admissions teams is seeing, understanding and reacting to the drift soon enough to do something about it.

Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#melt-isnt-a-surprise

Momentum, Not Motion: Three Ideas from the Next Era of SEM

A response to Brian Gann’s “Designing the Next Era of Strategic Enrollment Management” in AACRAO’s Strategic Enrollment Management Quarterly, Fall 2026

Brian Gann’s new AACRAO article argues that strategic enrollment management must shift from managing a pipeline to designing a system built around student momentum. Three of his ideas align closely with enroll ml’s work — and where we’d push them further.

At a glance

  • Brian Gann’s new AACRAO article argues that strategic enrollment management must shift from managing a pipeline to designing a system built around student momentum.
  • Three of his ideas align closely with enroll ml’s work: the student journey isn’t a pipeline, AI should build capacity rather than just automate, and momentum doesn’t stop at enrollment.
  • Much of today’s enrollment automation captures compliance, not intent. Students hit the milestones we push them toward, which makes those milestones weaker signals of real momentum.
  • Momentum lives between the milestones, and it runs through the entire student experience, from first evaluation to career and alumni engagement.
  • The Signal Solution, VantagePoint, and NetworkQst each focus on a different human strength (understanding behavior, strengthening judgment, and developing capability), and all three rest on one thesis: enrollment has been limited by cognition, not automation.

It’s not often that I read an article that so closely reflects what we’ve spent years thinking about, writing about, and building at enroll ml. But Brian Gann’s piece in the Fall 2026 issue of AACRAO’s Strategic Enrollment Management Quarterly, “Designing the Next Era of Strategic Enrollment Management,” comes remarkably close.

Brian, who leads enrollment and student services at Wake Technical Community College and is the incoming director of the AACRAO SEM Annual Conference, argues that SEM is at an inflection point. Fifty years in, the field has to move from coordinating functions to designing systems: bringing strategy, structure, data, technology, and practice together around how students actually move through an institution.

Three ideas in his piece line up closely with what Teege Mettille and I wrote in The Signal Solution, and with what we’ve built since. Here’s why they matter, and where we’d push them a little further.

1. The student journey isn’t a pipeline

Brian makes the case that the pyramid and the pipeline served enrollment management well for its first 50 years, but they no longer describe how students move. Fewer students travel in a straight line. They stop, swirl, transfer, change goals, and balance school with work and caregiving. His answer is to evolve SEM from pipeline management to what he calls “systems of momentum.”

When Teege and I wrote The Signal Solution, we drew on AI and machine learning analysis of real student behavior to make the same case. The funnel isn’t a factory line. It’s a decision cycle, and students move through it the way people actually make big decisions: messy, nonlinear, emotional, and smart.

We described that cycle in three phases, each built around a question the student is asking:

  1. “Do you have what I need?” The student is checking programs, cost, and whether they can get in.
  2. “Can I see myself here?” The student is wrestling with fit, belonging, and identity.
  3. “How do I complete?” The student has made the emotional leap and needs the logistics to be easy.

Students don’t move through these in order. They circle back, pause, and surge. And the middle phase is where yield is won or lost, which is exactly where most CRMs go blind.

Brian also makes a point about momentum that I want to underline. He defines it as more than speed through a process: it’s sustained movement toward goals students understand and value. We’d put it this way: motion isn’t momentum. A campus visit or a FAFSA submission is a milestone. But the question isn’t “Did they visit?” It’s “What changed after?” Did their engagement spike? Did they stall? Did they start asking new questions? Momentum, and the opportunity to change an outcome, hides between the milestones, not inside them.

2. AI should build capacity, not just automate

Brian is clear-eyed about AI. If institutions treat it only as a way to automate transactions or cut labor, he argues, they’ll get efficiency without transformation. Treated as capacity-building infrastructure, it can help them redesign how they support students at scale.

Among the governance questions he poses, one stopped me: how do we avoid simply automating a flawed process?

In The Signal Solution, Teege and I argued it’s already happening. Across dozens of institutions, from 500 students to 40,000, the admissions playbook is strikingly similar: the same drip campaigns, the same milestone triggers, the same dashboards. Somewhere along the way, we learned to mistake automation for strategy. We’re automating compliance, not intent.

Here’s why that matters. Historically, students have been remarkably compliant, and not because they’re passive. They’ll complete the tasks we ask of them, right up until the moment they firmly close the door on a college. Push them to submit a FAFSA and they’ll submit it. So when our campaigns push students toward the milestones that matter to us, they hit the milestones, and we read that as momentum. It isn’t. It’s one reason a FAFSA campaign can produce so little lift, and why the more telling signal is often the absence of a FAFSA.

Sometimes automation may actually work against us. In one partner’s data, our AI flagged a group of students who had shown high, consistent engagement and then withdrawn their applications. What they had in common: each withdrew right after an automated text pushing them to confirm their decision. These weren’t cold prospects. They were deep in the “Can I see myself here?” phase, and they needed space, not pressure. The AI pointed us to reactance theory, the psychology of people pushing back when they feel their freedom to choose is threatened. The institution wasn’t doing anything unusual. It was running the standard playbook, possibly at exactly the wrong moment.

Those are the principles we embedded into VantagePoint: AI that understands the ebb and flow of student decisions and translates it into advanced guidance for the people doing the work, instead of automating them away. It compresses sophisticated analysis, helps enrollment teams understand students more deeply, and points counselors to the moments that matter. When a student is showing subtle signs of uncertainty or disengagement but hasn’t reached out, that’s not a moment for another automated email. That’s a moment for a person. Our goal was never to replace the human spark in admissions. It was to force-multiply it.

3. Momentum doesn’t stop at enrollment

This is where Brian’s piece goes further than most writing on SEM, and where it connects to the next chapter of our work. His momentum system doesn’t end at census. It runs through persistence and completion, includes reengaging students who stopped out, and connects to post-completion outcomes and alumni engagement, with graduates linked to career networks and supporting the students who follow them.

We wrote about momentum inside the enrollment decision. But the philosophy, and the understanding of what student momentum really is, traverses the entire student experience. The journey ebbs and flows from a student’s first evaluation of a college, through the first term and the courses that make or break them, into a career, and back again as engaged alumni. The milestones change. The principle doesn’t. Momentum lives between the milestones, and the job is to see it early enough to help.

That’s why we’re extending VantagePoint into student success and retention. The same AI that reads the ebb and flow of an enrollment decision can read it in a student’s first year, and translate it into guidance for the advisors and success teams who can act on it.

And NetworkQst snaps in as the final piece, translating human connection into a career. It’s a gamified app that teaches students how to build and activate real professional networks as job seekers, and it helps career services teams give individualized guidance at scale. But its real contribution is different from VantagePoint’s. NetworkQst teaches students to do something no technology can do for them: build meaningful human relationships. The relationships that launch a career can’t be automated. They have to be learned.

Three challenges to one assumption

These aren’t separate ideas. The Signal Solution challenges how we understand students. VantagePoint challenges how we equip the people working with them. NetworkQst challenges how we prepare students to support themselves.

The first is about understanding human behavior. The second is about strengthening human judgment. The third is about developing human capability. And all three push back on the same assumption: that automation is what unlocks enrollment. Our thesis, and what we keep building against, is that enrollment has been limited by cognition, not automation. By our ability to see, interpret, and understand the ebbs and flows of the student journey, and turn them into strategies, actions, and human connections that help students.

That’s where our work and Brian’s meet. He closes by arguing that the future of SEM belongs to institutions that move beyond managing the pipeline to designing the system. We couldn’t agree more. And we’d add that the best-designed systems will be the ones that see students most clearly, and use that clarity to bring people closer to them, not further away.

If you work in enrollment management, student success, or career services, I encourage you to read Brian’s article.

Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#momentum-not-motion

Admissions Doesn’t Need Faster Execution. It Needs Deeper Understanding.

Recently, I’ve been asking enrollment leaders a simple question: If you could snap your fingers and make everyone on your admissions team smarter tomorrow, would you? The answer is always an immediate yes. But when I follow up with, “What exactly would change?” something interesting happens.

What if your entire enrollment team could think at a higher level?

Recently, I’ve been asking enrollment leaders a simple question: If you could snap your fingers and make everyone on your admissions team smarter tomorrow, would you?

The answer is always an immediate yes. But when I follow up with, “What exactly would change?” something interesting happens. There is usually a pause—sometimes a surprisingly long one.

That pause is revealing.

We have spent decades focused on productivity, efficiency, and scale, not on intellectual capacity. Imagine if every counselor, director, and vice president could recognize patterns, understand student motivations, assess available options, and exercise sound judgment with the collective knowledge, experience, and wisdom of the entire institution informing every decision they make.

Thousands of everyday decisions would improve. Problems would surface earlier. Strategic thinking would no longer be concentrated among a handful of experienced leaders. The result wouldn’t simply be a more productive enrollment organization; it would be a fundamentally more intelligent one.

The Limit of Automation: Instructions vs. Judgment

For decades, we’ve invested heavily in systems designed to collect, organize, and present information. We’ve built sophisticated CRMs, increasingly powerful dashboards, predictive models, and countless tools to improve efficiency. These technologies have created the impression that our teams are already operating with greater intelligence.

Counselors receive predictive scores, prioritized lists, recommended next actions, and automated messaging. But there is a crucial difference between receiving sophisticated instructions and exercising sophisticated judgment.

Consider a counselor equipped with all the modern tools. She begins her day with prioritized students and suggested actions. But does she know why a student’s behavior is changing, what matters most to them, or how to reach them as a person?

Imagine a student whose engagement has recently declined. A predictive model might lower that student’s likelihood-to-enroll score, moving them down the counselor’s priority queue. But a deeper examination of the student’s behavior reveals something quite different: the student recently attended a financial aid session, explored housing information, and stopped responding to general recruitment messages. Rather than losing interest, the student is likely wrestling with affordability or anxiety about the road ahead.

Those are two very different interpretations of the same data point, and they call for two very different responses:

The automated interpretation: Reduce outreach frequency to protect yield efficiency.

The deeper understanding: Initiate a candid, supportive conversation to help the student navigate a financial obstacle.

We have become remarkably good at telling admissions professionals what to do next, but far less effective at helping them understand why they should do it. That matters because the future of admissions depends on personal, intentional, and meaningful student engagement—not just faster execution.

You cannot automate your way into a thoughtful relationship.

Shifting Where Human Thinking Begins

This is where a new generation of reasoning-first AI represents something fundamentally different. When we built VantagePoint, our goal was not merely to organize more records or prescribe routine tasks; it was to fundamentally change where human thinking begins.

Instead of starting with “Who should I contact?” counselors can start with “Why is this student shifting, and how should I show up for them?”

Importantly, staff are no longer limited to their own tenure or intuition. They can draw upon the collective intelligence of the institution—informed by historical patterns, cross-departmental data, accumulated institutional knowledge, and strategic priorities.

Developing the instincts of a seasoned enrollment professional traditionally takes years of trial, error, and exposure to thousands of student interactions. Even the most dedicated counselor can only accumulate so much personal experience. But when that counselor approaches every conversation backed by what the institution has learned across decades of similar situations, the paradigm changes.

The goal is not to replace human judgment. It is to elevate it.

From Prescribed Dashboards to Strategic Inquiry

At the leadership level, this shift ensures strategy is no longer trapped in a few minds or behind closed boardroom doors. It becomes accessible in real time.

Through VantagePoint’s conversational capabilities, enrollment leaders can engage in direct, plain-English strategic dialogues with an AI system that understands their specific funnel, student demographics, and operational dynamics. Leaders can test assumptions, investigate emerging trends, and stress-test alternative strategies on demand—conversations that historically required weeks of coordination with data analysts and senior strategists.

Yet the most revealing reaction when leaders encounter this capability is often unexpected: “We don’t know what to ask.”

After decades of technology dictating what to look at and what to execute next, leaders are suddenly asked what they actually want to understand. That is an entirely different intellectual exercise.

The real promise of AI in admissions is not merely answering questions that once required a senior analyst. It is helping teams cultivate the curiosity, analytical rigor, and critical reasoning required to ask better questions in the first place.

Beyond Capacity: The Reasoning Advantage

The enrollment environment has permanently shifted. Student decision paths are increasingly non-linear, operating budgets are constrained, competition is aggressive, and the margin for error is razor-thin.

Yet the primary institutional response has been asking admissions teams to run the same playbook faster: send more emails, manage higher caseloads, and execute more tasks with fewer resources.

That approach has hit its ceiling.

The institutions that thrive will not be those that simply generate more activity. They will be the institutions that understand their students more deeply, recognize subtle shifts sooner, and respond with precision.

We’ve spent decades treating capacity as our primary obstacle, operating under the assumption that doing more work faster is the only answer to an increasingly complex enrollment landscape.

It isn’t. The next enrollment advantage isn’t capacity—it’s reasoning.

For years, higher education asked how technology could help admissions teams do more. The decisive question now is how it can help them think better. In an environment where thousands of individual decisions collectively determine institutional outcomes, the difference between those two questions will decide who thrives.

Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#deeper-understanding

From Nodding to Knowledge: Rethinking AI Trust in Higher Ed Administration

You know the moment. A new system gets introduced at the all-staff meeting. Heads nod around the table. Six months later, someone’s old spreadsheet is still running in the background. The real problem is quieter than a dashboard can show.

You know the moment. A new system gets introduced at the all-staff meeting. Leadership picked it, or a committee did, or it survived a lengthy RFP process, and everyone involved meant well. It was supposed to improve the work, the output, the efficiency, and the impact on students. Heads nod around the table.

Six months later, someone’s old spreadsheet is still running in the background, and the new tool sits with minimal use. Nobody announced it. Nobody needed to. But the usage numbers aren’t the problem, and pushing them up isn’t the solution.

The real problem is quieter than a dashboard can show. It’s trust, and it was living in higher education administration long before AI showed up. AI didn’t invent it, and it isn’t necessarily making it worse. But it is making it more visible, and it’s moving faster than our usual ways of closing the gap.

Trust was never the right starting point

It helps to ask what we already trust. Enrollment offices trust the CRM to hold every student in the funnel. Finance trusts the ERP to close the books. None of that trust arrived on day one. It was earned by people who understood what each system was for, what it did well, and where it stopped being useful.

We extend the same trust to people, often with less preparation than we’d ever accept from a system. Most admissions offices hire entry-level counselors, train them for a few weeks, and send them out to make thousands of recruiting decisions a day. Who to call. What to say. Which schools to visit. Which students need a second touch. We don’t call that a trust crisis. We call it onboarding, and we accept that judgment gets built over time, with coaching and someone to ask.

That’s the reframe. Whether it’s a system or a new counselor, trust is an outcome. What we actually need to build is understanding. When people understand a tool’s purpose, its limits, and how it changes their work, trust tends to follow. When they don’t, no amount of leadership enthusiasm fills the gap.

On the staff side, enthusiasm isn’t what’s missing. In EDUCAUSE’s 2026 study of AI and work in higher education, nearly 2,000 respondents, most of them administrators and staff, weighed in. Eighty-one percent felt enthusiasm or a mix of caution and enthusiasm, and 94% had used AI for work in the past six months. Only 54% knew of a policy guiding that use, and 56% had used tools their institution doesn’t provide.

I read that as a mix of two things. Some staff aren’t finding what they need inside the institution. Others trust their own judgment more than we realize. Either way, the use is happening. The question is whether understanding is keeping pace.

AI is a tool, not magic

Understanding starts with knowing what a tool is for. AI has boundaries, rules, and good and bad applications, like every tool before it. The campus tour golf cart is perfect for showing a family the quad. Sure, it has seats. It’s still not where you’d hold a sit-down meeting with that family. Nobody is confused about that, because we understand what a golf cart’s ideal purpose is.

We haven’t extended the same clarity to AI. Too often it arrives as a general answer, pointed at everything at once. When a tool is aimed at everything, can it really be good at anything? The tools that earn trust are aimed narrowly at a real problem someone can define. Defining the problem is the first step in fixing it. It’s also the first step in helping a team understand why the tool is in front of them.

From the nod to understanding

Go back to those nodding heads. Distrust rarely looks like pushback. It looks like a nodding head.

As a leader, it’s easy to get people to nod. It’s much harder to get them to understand. The real shift happens when someone can explain, in their own words, what the tool does, how it affects their work, and how it makes them better at their job. Getting there takes more time, patience, and listening than a kickoff meeting allows.

Committees still matter. Good plans often start there. EdTech Magazine recently made the case that the institutions getting this right treat the human side as seriously as the technical side, through governance and transparency. I agree, but AI moves faster than most committee cycles, and a policy document doesn’t build understanding at the desk level. Leaders do, by bringing understanding and accountability directly to their teams.

What leaders can do now

Start with the problem, not the tool. Before anything rolls out, the team should be able to name what it’s for and what it isn’t for. If that can’t be said plainly, it isn’t ready.

Put support inside the implementation. My doctoral research surveyed 150 enrollment management professionals who use AI. Their confidence during change was impacted most by whether they believed the tool improved their work and whether they felt supported by their institution. It didn’t relate to how often they used it. Support means a supervisor who knows the tool, help when someone gets stuck, and a visible sense that leadership is behind it.

Measure more than logins. Usage counts tell you people opened something, not that they understand it. EDUCAUSE found only 13% of respondents said their institution measures ROI on work-related AI. Whatever you measure should include whether people can explain the value. That starts with leaders, but it has to carry all the way down to and through the people using the tool.

Meet shadow AI with a conversation. When more than half of staff use tools the institution doesn’t provide, the first move is asking why. The answers show where the gaps in access, clarity, or trust actually sit.

Hold vendors to the same standard. Anyone selling AI into higher education owns part of this work. A vendor that hands off training and enablement at go-live has left the hardest part to the institution. Ask what support looks like at month six, not week one.

The work hasn’t changed

Trust has always been earned the same way in our offices. Someone understands what a thing is for, sees it make their work better, and knows someone is standing behind it. Nobody gets there by nodding. AI doesn’t change any of that. It just raises the cost of skipping it.

Sources

  • McIntosh, A. (2026, August 28). Why Trust Matters as Higher Ed Adopts AI Tools. EdTech: Focus on Higher Education.
  • Robert, J. (2026, January). The Impact of AI on Work in Higher Education. EDUCAUSE.
  • Kirby, E. K. (2026). The Effect of Artificial Intelligence Solutions on Employee Self-Efficacy in Post-Secondary Enrollment Management [Doctoral dissertation, Arkansas State University].
Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#nodding-to-knowledge

The Enrollment Problem We Keep Misdiagnosing

Every enrollment team I’ve led had a couple of counselors who could really read a student. What bothered me was that they could only think deeply about a few dozen students at a time, while the rest of the funnel got the campaign calendar and generic check-ins.

There’s a word behavioral economists use that most enrollment leaders have never heard, but would immediately recognize: satisficing.

It means settling for “good enough” instead of finding the best option — not because you don’t care, but because you don’t have time to evaluate everything. Herbert Simon coined it in the 1950s to describe how humans make decisions under constraints. It’s not a flaw. It’s a coping mechanism.

And it is the single most accurate description of how enrollment teams operate today.

The real problem isn’t effort. It’s capacity.

A typical admissions counselor manages 800 to 1,200 students. Each one has a different academic profile, communication history, financial situation, family dynamic, and timeline. The counselor also has travel weeks, events, committee work, and the pressure of hitting goals that shift mid-cycle.

No one in this job is being lazy. But the math doesn’t work.

When you’re managing that kind of volume, you triage. You check the CRM, scan for red flags, and move on. You send the same message to 40 students because writing 40 different messages isn’t possible by Thursday. You go with your gut on who to call first because there’s no time to analyze the data.

That’s satisficing. And it’s happening in every enrollment office in the country.

The industry’s response has made it worse.

For two decades, the answer to enrollment complexity has been: more tools. More dashboards. More workflows. More predictive scores. More automations. More “next steps.”

Each one adds a layer of information the counselor is supposed to process. But processing isn’t the bottleneck — thinking is. A counselor who already can’t evaluate 1,000 students deeply doesn’t benefit from another dashboard showing them the same 1,000 students from a different angle.

More data without more thinking capacity is just more noise.

What would actually help.

The solution to satisficing isn’t more willpower or more information. It’s better thinking infrastructure — systems that do the deep analysis humans can’t do at scale, so humans can focus on the decisions and relationships only they can handle.

Imagine a counselor starting their day and instead of scanning a dashboard, they get a briefing: “Here are the three students in your caseload who need attention today, why each one matters, and what the best approach is for each, written in your voice.”

That’s not automation. That’s augmentation. The counselor still decides. Still writes the email. Still makes the call. But the thinking that used to take 45 minutes of CRM archaeology has already been done.

Now multiply that across every counselor, every day, for every student in the funnel.

This is the cognitive ceiling.

We talk a lot about the enrollment cliff. But the more immediate problem is the cognitive ceiling — the gap between what enrollment teams are asked to accomplish and what’s humanly possible to think through.

The cliff is demographic. The ceiling is operational. And the ceiling is what teams hit every single day.

Satisficing is the symptom. The ceiling is the cause. And no amount of dashboards, automations, or predictive scores will raise it — because those tools don’t think. They display. They sort. They trigger. But they don’t reason about a student’s situation, weigh the trade-offs, and recommend what to do next.

The question has shifted.

Two years ago, the question was “Will AI work in enrollment?” That question is settled. The research is clear, the early adopters are seeing results, and the tools exist.

The question now is: “How will we do it?”

And the answer matters enormously, because not all AI is the same. A chatbot that auto-responds to inquiries is AI. A system that reasons through every student in your funnel every day, weighs their signals, considers your institutional voice, and delivers personalized strategic guidance to each counselor — that’s a different thing entirely.

The first replaces a task. The second raises the ceiling.

What this means for your team.

If you lead an enrollment team, you already know the satisficing problem — you just may not have had a word for it. You see it when counselors default to batch communication. When territory strategies don’t get updated mid-cycle. When leadership questions take weeks to answer because the data is scattered.

The fix isn’t asking your team to work harder. It’s giving them thinking infrastructure that matches the complexity of what they’re being asked to do.

That’s what breaking through the cognitive ceiling actually looks like. Not more tools. Not more data. Better thinking — at scale, in real time, for every student, every day.

Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#enrollment-misdiagnosis

AI in Enrollment: A Balanced Perspective

AI has the ability to elevate enrollment teams and make everyone more effective. It also carries aspects to clarify and approach through a cautious lens. This guide treats both sides seriously.

I spend a significant amount of time talking with enrollment leaders about AI. Some are moving quickly and others are skeptical. I wanted a resource that treated both sides seriously: what the evidence says AI can improve, where the risks are real, and the questions enrollment teams should ask before adopting it.

This approach draws on research and guidance from EDUCAUSE, NACAC, the U.S. Department of Education, NIST, the International Energy Agency, and academic studies, not on vendor claims. Skeptical perspectives are included on purpose, because addressing those questions often lays the foundation for smooth adoption.

AI is already here, though its applications have materially different consequences, and enrollment leaders need to understand those distinctions well enough to make deliberate choices. Please share this freely.

Two kinds of AI, and why the difference matters

“AI” as a blanket term covers a vast landscape, and most disagreement about it comes from various perspectives. A useful split is between AI that replaces a task and AI that supports a person’s judgment.

Task automation Judgment support (augmentation)
What it does Performs a task instead of a person: chatbots, auto-sent messages, AI “recruiter” agents Gives a person better information or a first draft; now smarter, the person decides and acts
Who is accountable The system; challenging to audit without human review The staff member, who stays in the loop
Main risk Errors reach students directly; human contact shrinks Staff lean on it too heavily and stop employing judgement
Effect on jobs in research to date Linked to fewer entry-level roles Employment flat or rising

The labor research backs the distinction. A 2025 Stanford Digital Economy Lab analysis of payroll data and revised in August 2026 found employment for workers aged 22 to 25 in AI-exposed jobs ran 19% below trend. The declines were concentrated where AI substitutes for work; where it complements work, employment held or grew (Brynjolfsson, Chandar and Chen). The authors call these early indicators, not settled causal findings.

For an enrollment office, the practical question is not “AI or no AI.” It is which tasks, if any, a team is comfortable handing to a machine, and which it wants a machine to help elevate people and their impact.

Where AI is helping

Some of the strongest field evidence so far shows AI substantially improving human performance, especially for newer or less-experienced staff, when it is designed to augment rather than replace them.

  • Newer staff get up to speed faster. In a study of 5,179 customer support agents, AI assistance raised issues resolved per hour by 14% on average and by 35% for the least experienced. Agents with two months on the job performed like six-month veterans. Customer sentiment improved and attrition fell (NBER, Brynjolfsson, Li and Raymond). Support work is not admissions counseling, but the pattern of lifting newer staff is relevant to offices with turnover.
  • Small teams can cover more ground. After budget and staffing cuts, many offices carry more students per counselor. Tools that help sort who needs attention now, and who is fine for the moment, let people spend limited hours where they matter most.
  • Leaders get answers faster. Questions about the funnel that once waited weeks for an analyst can be explored in hours. The value is in asking better questions more often, not in the tool deciding.
  • Less time on drafting and repetition. A first draft of a routine message or a summary of a student’s history frees time for the conversations only a person can have.
  • Staff are already using it. In a January 2026 EDUCAUSE survey of 1,960 higher education professionals, 94% had used AI for work in the prior six months, and 56% had used tools their institution did not provide (EDUCAUSE). A deliberate, approved approach is often safer than the unmanaged use already happening.

The common thread: benefits show up when AI hands a person better information and the person stays in charge of the decision and the relationship.

The risks and limitations

These risks are documented, not hypothetical, and none of them disappears because a tool is well built. Each can be reduced with the right practices.

Risk What the evidence shows What reduces it
Bias in predictions Models predicting college success wrongly flagged 19% of Black and 21% of Hispanic students as likely to fail, against 12% of White and 6% of Asian students. No single fix fully removed the gap (Gándara et al., AERA Open 2024) Test results by student group, train staff to spot bias, never let a score alone decide
Wrong or invented answers Misinformation is the top AI concern of higher ed staff, named by 55% (EDUCAUSE 2026) A person reviews anything before it reaches a student; the tool shows its reasoning
Privacy and consent 52% of staff worry about data used without consent; 51% about weak data protection (same survey) FERPA terms in the contract, limits on data use, no training on student records without consent
Overreliance In a survey of 319 knowledge workers, more confidence in AI went with less critical thinking (Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon, 2025) Treat output as a second opinion; ask staff to explain why they agree or disagree
Less human contact Automated outreach can make students feel processed rather than known Use AI behind the scenes to prepare people, not in place of them
Cost and lock-in Subscriptions add up, and switching can be hard once workflows depend on a tool Clear success measures, data export rights, contract terms

The bias finding deserves the most attention. Predictive tools learn from past outcomes, and past outcomes reflect past inequities. A tool that is not checked for this can quietly steer attention away from the students an institution most wants to serve.

Environmental and community impact

The environmental cost of one person’s AI use is small, but the combined build-out of data centers is large and lands hard on specific communities. Both matter, and staff who have seen the local effects are raising a fair concern.

The big picture

Data centers used about 415 TWh of electricity in 2024, roughly 1.5% of global use. The International Energy Agency expects that to more than double to about 945 TWh by 2030, just under 3% of global use, with the U.S. and China driving nearly 80% of the growth (IEA, Energy and AI). The IEA also notes AI could save energy elsewhere, but says the net effect is not guaranteed (IEA).

The individual picture

Google reports its median Gemini text prompt uses 0.24 watt-hours, about nine seconds of television, and 0.26 mL of water, about five drops (Google Cloud). These are company-reported figures; outside researchers have questioned what they leave out, and image, video and heavy analytic workloads cost more.

What this means for a decision

Declining to use a tool in one office will not change the regional build-out, and using one will not meaningfully add to it. What an institution can control is its choices: prefer vendors who disclose where and how they host, favor focused tools over heavy open-ended use, and include environmental questions in procurement alongside cost and privacy. It is also reasonable for staff to hold these concerns and name them openly as part of the conversation.

Common staff concerns, answered honestly

Most staff concerns about AI are reasonable, and some are partly right. Here is what the evidence supports and where it is still unsettled.

Concern What the evidence says What would help
“This is about replacing us.” Partly valid. Entry-level roles in AI-exposed jobs have declined where AI substitutes for work; roles where AI supports people have held steady or grown Leadership states plainly what the tool is for and what it is not for
“It will make recruiting impersonal.” Valid for automated outreach. Less so when AI works behind the scenes and people still have the conversations Keep every student-facing message reviewed or written by a person
“How do I know I can trust it?” Trust should be earned, not assumed. Over-trusting AI is linked to less critical thinking Tools that show why they recommend something; where staff check it against their own judgment
“It will be used to monitor my performance.” Depends entirely on how leadership chooses to use it Agree up front on what data is and is not used for evaluation
“It is bad for the environment and my community.” The regional impact of data centers is real; one office’s use is a small share Ask vendors about hosting and efficiency; make it part of the decision
“It is one more system to learn.” Valid, especially after budget cuts leave fewer people carrying more work Choose tools that fit existing systems; budget time for training, not just licenses

The people raising these concerns are often the ones who care most about students. Their questions belong in the evaluation, not outside it.

Guardrails that make adoption work

The professional and legal standards enrollment offices already follow give a sound starting framework for AI. Three are most useful.

NACAC’s ethical guide

The 2026 edition asks members to “promote ethical practices in relation to the use of artificial intelligence” in line with “transparency, integrity, fairness, and respect for student dignity,” and to protect student data privacy “across all platforms, applications and technologies” (NACAC Guide to Ethical Practice).

FERPA

A vendor that handles student records can act as a “school official” only if it performs a service staff would otherwise do, stays under the institution’s direct control over how records are used and kept, and follows limits on redisclosure (34 CFR 99.31). Those conditions belong in the contract, not just the sales conversation.

NIST AI Risk Management Framework

A voluntary federal framework, released January 2023 with a generative AI profile added July 2024, organized around four functions: Govern, Map, Measure and Manage (NIST). It is a practical checklist for campus IT and governance committees.

Taken together, those standards suggest a practical set of working rules for enrollment teams:

  1. A person makes every decision that affects a student. AI informs; it does not decide.
  2. Nothing AI drafts reaches a student without a person reviewing it.
  3. Results are checked by student group at least once a cycle for uneven accuracy.
  4. Staff know what data the tool uses and can explain a recommendation in plain words.
  5. The institution owns its data, can export it, and can end the contract cleanly.
  6. Security is verified through standard documentation such as SOC 2 reports and the HECVAT, with single sign-on where campus policy requires it.

Questions to ask any AI vendor

A good vendor will welcome these questions and answer them in writing. Vague answers are a signal in themselves.

Purpose and people

  • Does the tool act on its own, or does it inform a staff member who acts?
  • Which student-facing actions, if any, happen without a person approving them?
  • How do you expect our team’s daily work to change, and what training do you provide?

Accuracy and fairness

  • Can staff see why the tool made a given recommendation?
  • How do you test accuracy across student groups, and will you share those results for our data?
  • What happens when staff disagree with the tool, and does that feedback improve it?

Data and privacy

  • Will you sign FERPA school official terms, and what exactly do you do with our records?
  • Is our data used to train models for other clients?
  • Can we export our data and have it deleted when the contract ends?
  • Can you provide a SOC 2 report and a completed HECVAT, and do you support single sign-on?

Cost and environment

  • What is the full cost, including setup, integration and staff time?
  • Where is the tool hosted, and what do you disclose about its energy use?
  • What would a limited pilot look like, and how would we measure it?

A practical path to adoption

The most reliable way to earn buy-in is to involve skeptics in the evaluation and let results, not promises, make the case.

  1. Start with a real problem. Name one specific pain point or opportunity, such as too many students per counselor or slow answers to leadership questions, before looking at any tool.
  2. Put skeptics on the evaluation team. Their questions will find weaknesses early and make the decision more credible to everyone else.
  3. Ground rules first. What the tool will and will not be used for, including performance evaluation, agreed before anything is bought.
  4. Check the output side by side. Staff compare the tool’s suggestions with their own judgment and record where they differ.
  5. Review fairness and environmental questions openly. Share results by student group and the vendor’s hosting answers with the whole team.

Sources and further reading

Work and productivity

  • Generative AI at Work, Brynjolfsson, Li and Raymond, NBER
  • Canaries in the Coal Mine? Six Facts about the Recent Employment Effects of AI, Stanford Digital Economy Lab
  • The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking, Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon

Higher education

  • The Impact of AI on Work in Higher Education, EDUCAUSE, 2026
  • Algorithms Used by Universities to Predict Student Success May Be Racially Biased, AERA, 2024
  • Guide to Ethical Practice in College Admission, NACAC, 2026 edition

Law and governance

  • 34 CFR 99.31, FERPA disclosure conditions
  • AI Risk Management Framework, NIST

Energy and environment

  • Energy and AI: Energy demand from AI, International Energy Agency
  • Key Questions on Energy and AI, International Energy Agency
  • Quick Facts: Data Centers in Ohio, Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel
  • How data centers impact Ohio’s electricity prices, Axios Columbus, August 2025
  • Measuring the environmental impact of AI inference, Google Cloud
Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#ai-balanced-perspective

The Signal Hiding in Rural Student Behavior

What happens when you stop surveying rural students about why they don’t enroll — and start looking at how they actually behave in the funnel.

This is an interesting article by Johanna Alonso in Inside Higher Ed on the University of Tennessee’s efforts to attract more rural students.

We worked on a very similar problem about two years ago with another R1 state flagship. The question, coming from the state legislature, was pretty straightforward: why were in-state rural students enrolling at a lower rate than non-rural students?

The institution had already surveyed this extensively. We took a different approach — using our ensemble machine learning models, trained on historical enrollment data, to look for behavioral pattern differences between rural and non-rural students. In this process we reviewed 3 years of enrollment history, ~150 native enrollment data elements and ~350 newly engineered data points for every student.

The finding

Perhaps the most interesting finding was that the institution’s bulk communications appeared to work differently for rural students. The standard post-admit workflows and campaigns — how many emails were sent, opened, clicked and responded to in some form — were a noticeably weaker predictor of whether a rural student would enroll.

The same flow that served as a strong signal for the broader population wasn’t doing the same for rural students.

A thesis worth testing

This didn’t tell us exactly why rural students were enrolling at lower rates. But it did give us a thesis worth exploring: what if rural students needed (or wanted) a different post-admit communications and interaction chain?

Like a lot of large institutions, this one moved essentially everyone through the same post-admit flow. A new branch of this chain — built specifically for rural students — could mean different content, voice, volume, channel and pacing, built around how rural students were actually engaging with the institution.

The bigger point

There’s no simple answer here, and the Tennessee story has its own tensions. But sometimes the objective isn’t to wait for the definitive answer. It’s to use the data to build a new thesis, test it, and see if you can move the outcome.

Underneath the comms flows and probabilities, and behind the surveys, there’s a lot of previously unseen behavioral data that can help enrollment teams work with much more precision on the objectives that matter most.

Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#rural-student-signal

The Courage to Rethink

The hard part of AI in enrollment isn’t choosing the right tool. It’s the willingness to ask whether the strategies you’ve relied on for years still make sense.

I was in Chicago this week at Roosevelt University. Grateful to Scott Clyde and Mike Dolen for being part of the conversation, and to Roosevelt for hosting.

We talked about AI. The tools, the frameworks. That conversation matters.

But the tech isn’t the hard part.

The hard part is that when the pressure is on, every instinct tells you to go back to what you know. We’re too busy to change course. We already invested in this. The playbook feels safe, or at least less risky. Staying the course feels like control. It’s not. It’s just comfort.

That’s the real hurdle right now. Not choosing the right AI tool. It’s the willingness to ask whether the strategies you’ve relied on for years still make sense.

Drop your tools.

Adam Grant opens Think Again with a story about smokejumpers caught in a wildfire. The ones who survived dropped their tools and ran. The ones who didn’t held on to equipment built for a different situation. They weren’t undertrained. They just couldn’t let go.

The question Grant keeps returning to is “How do you know?” Not as a challenge. As an invitation to separate what you’ve tested from what you’ve repeated.

The willingness to put something down that used to work is what separates adaptation from exhaustion.

Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#courage-to-rethink

Enrollment Still Solves. The Question Is How.

A reflection on the fight to save Antioch College, the yield math that changes everything, and why AI’s real role in admissions is strategic advisor — not task executor.

This is a great read about the fight to save Antioch College by Jonathon Podolsky in Medium — and I appreciate the reference to The Signal Solution.

I’ve seen this movie: I spent several years working in high-urgency higher ed turnarounds, often being the villain in the story — challenging unsustainable marketing spending, accelerating cost reductions, optimizing programs, sections and schedules, killing capital projects that didn’t substantively change outcomes, restructuring debt, searching for auxiliary revenue, challenging longstanding pricing methodologies, and sitting across from skeptical accreditors.

None of those were popular moves. But there are very few levers that can change trajectory quickly, especially in an industry that doesn’t exactly have a reputation for moving quickly, and where every down enrollment year compounds.

You have to find a way to grow enrollment.

Jonathon highlights something that sounds obvious from the outside, but can feel almost impossible from the inside: you have to find a way to grow enrollment.

In those situations, my focus almost instantly shifted to yield. The math is pretty compelling. A 15% yield rate means 85 out of every 100 admitted students said no. Find just 3 more students among those 85 and you’ve grown enrollment 20%, without increasing your cost of new student acquisition.

That’s why I appreciated Jonathon’s reference to Teege Mettille’s and my book, The Signal Solution.

The old playbook isn’t coming back.

The old playbook of driving more top-of-funnel volume and expecting enrollment growth to follow doesn’t work the way it once did. And it’s not coming back.

We have to transform how our technology and our teams drive enrollment. That means getting dramatically better at understanding and competing for the students already in the funnel, and giving our people the intelligence to know where and how their attention can make the greatest difference.

Strategic advisor, not task executor.

This is where AI can fundamentally change admissions. Not simply by sorting, automating, or telling a counselor who to call next, but by thinking deeply alongside the team. Understanding the full context of an individual student. Connecting signals across time and systems. Helping uncover the nuance behind what a student may be doing, thinking, or signaling.

That is a massively strategic role for AI in enrollment: strategic advisor, not just task executor.

Colleges are confronting foundational challenges around cost, pricing transparency, outcomes and value, and now an AI-driven teaching and learning environment.

The playbook built for a different era should not be expected to perform the same way in this one. Admissions has to transform and elevate.

Enrollment still solves. The question is whether we are willing to build the admissions organizations capable of solving it now.

Link to this article: enrollml.com/perspectives.html#antioch-yield-math

Want to learn how enroll ml can transform your enrollment strategy?

Let’s Talk